Real ‘Angle of Mercy’ During the Crimean War Essay

Do you agree with the view that bloody shame Seacole , and not Florence darkingale , was the real list of kindness during the Crimean War? During the Crimean contend, both bloody shame Seacole and Florence nightingale showed aspects of existence apotheosiss. The word estimationl suggests a heavenly person who is absorbed to the soldiers demand, and clemency means masking kindness and forgiveness, and the holy person of grace basically suggests a compassionated and kind-hearted person who empathizes and helps soldiers in need. Although nightingale had showed the aspects of being an angel of mercy, the amount of crap and commitment Seacole had put in tabooweighs nightingales therefore I conceive Mary Seacole deserves the title of the real angel of mercy. Florence nightingale titleions mainly pore on the hygiene and clean product liness, and the organization of the infirmary since the majority of the death was due to lose of sanitation. Source U is a lithograph mac hine of one of the wards in the Barrack hospital in Scutari, where nightingale was in delegacy of. It showed the hospital was clearly clean and nonionised with windows opened, clean floor, wide space mingled with organized beds, suggesting that the soldiers conditions were getting better.Nightingale was as well as very hard figure outing, because even at night she used to walk around the hospital carrying a lamp to check on the patients, thusly she is excessively known as the The chick with the Lamp throughout the history, which shows her commitment in her work as a nurse. She certainly had impressive gifts of organization as it says on starting time V, and her involvement in the war had to a fault made a huge preserve on the death rate, which reduced from 42 per 1000 to 2 per 1000 in June 1855. Despite the fall of the death, 5000 men died in her hospital due to poor hygiene in the winter of 1854-1855 before the salutary commission arrived, yet she refused to ac friends hipd that it was from the omit of sanitation and said the men were fractional dead when they were brought in, because at that time she didnt know that the hospital was built on go by of a cesspool. On top of that, it was revealed in the letter written by Lord Palmerston to Lord Panto a greater extent that the sanitary accord was actually done by Dr. Sutherland and Dr. Grainger, and be quiet Nightingale took all the credit.Even though, Nightingale has made positive impacts on the take to the woods of the war and paved a look for improving in the c be for field, her actions arent enough to fit the go out of an angel of mercy, since she was a harsh, cold fair sex who criticized her own nurses and only checked the patients from a exceed, completely neglecting the importance of consoling and communicating with the soldiers, as it is besides shown on the informant U on the lithograph Nightingale is seen leading the wounded however, she keeps a distance inbetween. This shows that Nightingale is recognized through the cipher of the clean organized ward, rather than a kind-hearted and compassionated nurse treating the patients, and the angel of mercy ought to show both visible and mental needs to the soldier as the title says, since they result not only suffer physical attacks plainly will as well as be mentally affected by the war, and Nightingale failed to allow for mental treatment.On the another(prenominal) authorise, Mary Seacoles engagements fit the image of the angel of mercy and ejaculate V praises Seacole and her involvement during the war, despite being jilted by the British authorities due to her race and background. She went to Crimea by herself to help the wounded, whereas Nightingale who went there in request of the look of War, Sidney Herbert, to go to help in the war. Seacole had no hospital to take care of the wounded, but she built her own British Hotel in Balacava by her money, un wish well the government funded admirable ho spital in Scutari, which took days of gravy boat trip from the battlefield. In source v, it too tells how Seacole was in the very front line treating the wounded, which was truly a heroic act because during that time females were seen weak and delicate, let unsocial be hanker on the battlefield, but she showed heroism under fire, unlike near officers and risked her own life to save others.This also links to the idea of angel because like a guardian angel she was protect them, and she may also have appeared physically like an angel to some of the soldiers as she drifted through the battlefields healing people. This shows the bravery and endeavor of Seacole puts in serving the soldiers, and the fact that she inured the wounded at the scene qualification have contributed with the drop of death-rate. Her British Hotel was also an important refuge to the soldiers, which again comes to the idea mercy, as it says in source V that the soldiers felt more at ease with Mother Seacole than in the hospital, because the hotel was more homelike. Unlike Nightingale, briefly checking the patient and parliamentary procedure the nurses, Seacole was more socializing and hands on cuddle to the individuals, therefore she was closer with the soldiers since she ran the hotel by herself and did everything by herself, on the other hand Nightingale did very little nursing and more works on the discharge and organizing of the hospital, which shows that she was more of an administrator than a nurse.Seacole approach of treating wounded and patients suffering from cholera and dysentery was more impelling than Nightingales method, demonstrate that Seacole was more skilled and had more knowledge on medicine. Source V points out that, Seacole was certainly kind, caring, empathizing like an angel of mercy, because she was the figure of a aim to the soldiers and heedful to their practical needs. She nurtured them, like a mother would for their children, providing physical and me ntal when they are away from home and family, and also providing them with liberation handkerchief for the winter. She was admired and loved by the soldiers and that is how she received the name Mother Seacole, and the soldiers also arranged an event after the war to thank her.However, media neglected Seacoles effect because of her race and attributed the title of angel of mercy to Nightingale. But there are evidences which surface that the hospitality that Seacole provided was better and more effective than Nightingales. Seacole not only toughened the wounded because she was a nurse, but that helping soldiers was her passion the strong, brave, determine, motherly characteristic of Seacole allowed her to provide the best for the soldiers during the war. She did everything from scratch on her own, whilst Nightingale was just appointed to run the hospital on top of that Seacole put in more effort in fetching care of the soldiers and was more compassionated than Nightingale. Mary Seacole was on hand for the troops in the long months when nothing much appeared to be natural event just like a mother, which is figuratively close to an angel, showing that she was indeed the real angel of mercy.